Why Returns Management Is Critical for eCommerce Success in 2025

Katherine Wroth • November 21, 2024
Handling returns remains one of the biggest challenges for merchants in the new year.


In 2024, eCommerce companies faced significant hurdles in managing returns. With $743 billion worth of merchandise returned in 2023, many retailers updated their returns policies to prepare for the year ahead. Now that peak season has ended, eCommerce merchants are navigating a surge of returns extending far beyond the holiday rush. Here are four key reasons why returns management is critical for e-commerce success in 2025.



1. Economic Uncertainty Drives Cost Management


With the current economic climate, retailers focus on balancing costs across supply chains, including returns management. Despite economic uncertainties, eCommerce sales are projected to grow faster than they have since 2021, accounting for 19.8% of total sales, the most significant increase since 2020, according to eMarketer. This surge necessitates balancing cost management and delivering exceptional customer experiences. Automating returns processes can unlock cost savings while retaining customer loyalty.


2. Consumer Behavior Shifts Increase Returns


Retail Dive reports that 87% of consumers intentionally order additional items to try on at home, returning the ones they don't want to keep. This practice, known as "bracketing," has become a common trend among shoppers. This behavior introduces unpredictability in margin calculations, inventory management and operations workflows. Notably, 64% of consumers make returns in apparel, shoes and accessories more often than any other product.


3. Implementing Return Fees and Customer Loyalty


Retailers are considering return fees to manage costs, which raises concerns about customer loyalty. Some merchants find that customers will pay reasonable return fees if the return experience is positive. Retailers must assess customers' price sensitivity and develop fee policies that balance cost management with customer satisfaction.


4. Preparing for Returns Fraud and Policy Abuse


Loop Returns research shows that returns fraud and policy abuse are rising, with 53% of US merchants citing returns fraud as a significant challenge. To combat this, retailers are tightening returns eligibility criteria and requiring more detailed information at checkout while striving to maintain positive returns experiences for loyal customers. Implementing eligibility tiers via loyalty programs can offer more lenient returns policies to loyal customers, helping protect against potential returns abuse.


Barrett Distribution's Approach


At Barrett Distribution, we understand the complexities of returns management during peak season. Our tailored solutions focus on cost-effective, customer-centric returns processes. By leveraging automation and data analytics, we help retailers navigate economic uncertainties, adapt to shifting consumer behaviors and implement effective policies to mitigate fraud and abuse.


As the peak season calms, partnering with a logistics provider experienced in returns management is essential. Barrett is committed to helping retailers optimize their returns processes, ensuring a seamless experience for businesses and customers.


Facing returns challenges? Contact us today for a complimentary supply chain consultation.

Recent Blog Posts

By Faith Artieda May 7, 2026
On May 4, 2026, our Franklin, MA facility achieved a milestone that reflects that commitment: a perfect score of 1000 on its AIB (American Institute of Baking) food safety audit—the first perfect score in Barrett history. For brands operating in food, beverage, and consumable categories, this achievement represents more than a number. It’s a clear signal of the discipline, consistency, and attention to detail required to protect product integrity across the supply chain. What an AIB Audit Measures—and Why It Matters An AIB audit is one of the most rigorous food safety evaluations in the industry. It assesses a facility’s ability to maintain: Cleanliness and sanitation standards Operational controls and process discipline Regulatory compliance and documentation Facility maintenance and structural integrity For brands, especially those managing consumable or regulated products, these standards are critical. A failure in any of these areas can lead to product risk, compliance issues, or damage to brand reputation. From 990 to 1000: A Culture of Continuous Improvement The Franklin team’s achievement didn’t happen overnight. After earning an outstanding score of 990 in the previous audit, the team set a clear and ambitious goal: reach a perfect 1000. What followed was a disciplined, detail-oriented approach to closing every gap. Through weekly audit preparation calls, consistent follow-up, and a strong focus on execution, the team elevated every aspect of the operation. The result was a facility operating at the highest possible standard—where even the smallest details were addressed. Floors were spotless, the environment was free of dust and debris, and every element of the building met or exceeded expectations. This wasn’t incremental improvement. It was precision execution. Operational Excellence Is a Team Effort Achievements like this reflect the strength of the entire operation—not just one function. From operations leadership and supervisors to safety and maintenance teams, every role contributed to the outcome. Strong documentation, proactive facility upkeep, and disciplined daily execution all played a part in achieving a perfect score. This level of alignment is what enables Barrett to deliver consistent, reliable performance for customers in highly regulated industries. What This Means for Barrett Customers For brands evaluating a 3PL partner, certifications and audit scores aren’t just credentials—they’re indicators of how your product will be handled every day. A perfect AIB score demonstrates: A food-safe, audit-ready environment Strong inventory and process controls A culture built on accountability and continuous improvement Confidence that your products are handled with the highest level of care For customers in food, beverage, health, and beauty, that level of rigor directly translates to reduced risk and stronger operational performance. Setting the Standard Moving Forward This milestone is a proud moment for the Franklin team—but it also reflects something broader across Barrett. Our approach to warehousing and fulfillment is rooted in discipline, visibility, and execution. Whether supporting food-grade operations or complex omnichannel distribution, we focus on delivering consistent results at scale.  Because in today’s supply chain environment, excellence isn’t occasional—it has to be repeatable.
By Faith Artieda April 23, 2026
How Barrett eliminates inefficiencies across the supply chain to reduce waste, lower costs, and improve performance.
Choosing a 3PL Partner: What Matters Most?
By Megan Krauss April 20, 2026
Choosing a 3PL partner? See what matters most to brands, from customer service and inventory accuracy to speed and technology.
More Posts